When a REAL ID Isn’t Enough
ICE Wrongfully Detains a U.S. Citizen
Truth Telling isn’t free subscribe now for 33% off one year
Earlier this month, a U.S. citizen—carrying a federally issued REAL ID—was wrongfully detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Yes, you read that correctly: a U.S. citizen, armed with the very identification that was supposed to verify their legitimacy, was taken into custody by a federal agency whose job is supposedly to target undocumented individuals. The detention only ended when ICE realized their mistake and released the individual.
How does this happen in a country that claims to value civil liberties and due process?
The Broken Machinery of ICE
This is not an isolated incident. From 2007 to 2023, hundreds of U.S. citizens have been detained or deported because ICE either didn’t verify information thoroughly—or didn’t care to. In many of these cases, the victims were Black or Brown. It’s impossible to ignore the role of racial profiling in how immigration enforcement is carried out in this country.
What does it say about the system when even citizenship doesn’t shield you from ICE’s dragnet?
This isn't just about bureaucracy or human error—this is about a system built on dehumanization, fear, and racialized control.
REAL ID: A False Sense of Security
The REAL ID Act was sold to Americans as a way to make identification more secure and trustworthy. But if having a REAL ID in your wallet doesn’t stop ICE from detaining you, then what’s the point?
This isn't a technical failure. This is a policy failure. A training failure. A cultural failure inside of ICE that sees certain bodies—especially immigrant, Brown, or non-English-speaking bodies—as automatically suspect.
We cannot afford to normalize these errors. When state violence operates without meaningful accountability, it always expands its reach. It does not stop with undocumented immigrants. It doesn’t stop with asylum seekers. Eventually, it knocks on the door of citizens too—especially those who don't “look” American enough in the eyes of the state.
The Urgency of Oversight and Reform
We need to get real about the danger of unaccountable immigration enforcement. If ICE can detain citizens without consequence, what does that mean for the millions of people who live in daily fear of deportation?
Congress must act. Federal and state agencies must implement immediate safeguards. And the American public must understand that this is not just an immigration issue—it’s a civil rights crisis.
We are witnessing the consequences of a system that values speed and suspicion over justice and truth. If we allow this to continue unchecked, we are complicit.